Showing posts with label smart meters. Show all posts
Showing posts with label smart meters. Show all posts

Monday, October 14, 2013

BC Hydro customers keeping old meters must pay $35 monthly: BCUC

BY BRIAN MORTON, VANCOUVER SUN OCTOBER 14, 2013 1:05 PM
BC Hydro customers can keep their old anologue meters for a surcharge of $35 monthly if they opt out at the end of the year, the B.C. Utilities Commission (BCUC) has announced. In a decision allowing all approved charges on an interim basis, customers can also choose to accept a new smart meter and pay $100 to disable its radio transmitter, and then pay an additional $20 a month for manual readings. The fees would be in place Dec. 2. Hydro, which had applied to the province's independent power regulator for the fees to cover costs for people opting out of the smart meter grid, has said the fees will only cover costs, and aren’t meant to generate a profit. Hydro announced the smart meter opt-out program in July after strong opposition by many residents left the $1-billion provincewide program with more than 60,000 holdouts. Critics said they were worried about the smart meter’s wireless radio transmissions hurting their health, while others insisted they were being bullied into accepting the meters by installers. The Crown power corporation said the fees are necessary to offset the expense of manually reading meters for customers. The new smart meters wirelessly transmit power data directly to Hydro. It is application to BCUC, Hydro said it began contacting eligible customers to notify them of the meter choices in early September and that the enrolment period ends on December 1.

Friday, September 13, 2013

Cost For Smart Meter Holdouts


Smart meterWritten by 107.5 Kiss FM Friday, 13 September 2013 11:06 
It won't be cheap for BC Hydro customers who don't want a smart meter.  The Crown corporation has sent letters to customers, saying those that choose to have smart meters installed but have the radio transmitter shut off, will be charged a one-time fee of $100, plus $20 a month for manual readings. Hydro says those who don't confirm a choice by December 1 will automatically be charged a $35 monthly fee and left with their old meter. There's about 60-thousand holdouts, while about 1.6 million, or 96 percent of Hydro's customers, have accepted the new meters.

Thursday, July 18, 2013

B.C. government backs down completely on smart meters

By Jonathan Fowlie, Vancouver Sun July 18, 2013 12:25 PM
VICTORIA - The B.C. government has backed down completely on smart meters, saying people can now keep the old-style analog meters in place if they are willing to pay a fee. "This decision finds an appropriate balance between addressing the concerns raised by people who have put their meter installation on hold, while ensuring that the majority of customers who have a standard smart meter will not be paying for those who select an opt out option," Energy Minister Bill Bennett said in a news release. “I believe that this is a fair and reasonable solution for all British Columbians." People who keep the old meters will be charged a monthly fee that will include both the extra cost of reading the meter and the cost of instituting duplicate systems. The announcement comes about a week after Bennett floated an option of giving people a smart meter with the radio turned off. That option is still available, but people who chose that option will be charged a one-time fee to modify the meter plus a monthly fee to read the meter. Government had for more than two years said every analog meter in the province needed to be replaced by a smart meter. Under the new program, people who keep their analog meters will only be able to do so until the meter breaks down, their Measurement Canada seal expires or they relocate. After that, the analog meter will be replaced with a smart meter with the radio feature disabled. About 60,000 have refused to have a smart meter installed.
-------------

VICTORIA – Bill Bennett, Minister of Energy and Mines, announced today that BC Hydro will offer new options for customers who have put their smart meters on hold. 
Government is responding to public concerns by providing opt-out options with the costs borne by those customers and not subsidized by the majority, who have a standard BC Hydro smart meter. BC Hydro customers who do not currently have a smart meter will now have three choices:
·         Choose the standard smart meter at no cost.
·         Accept a digital meter with the radio off. This option will be subject to a one-time cost to modify the meter plus a monthly fee to read the meter.
·         Keep the old analog meter, which will be subject to a monthly fee that will include both the extra cost of reading the meter and the cost of instituting duplicate systems.

Costs and fees associated with the options will be established by BC Hydro but will be reviewed by the BC Utilities Commission to ensure that BC Hydro is only recovering the cost of providing and servicing the radio-off and analog options.


Thursday, July 11, 2013

B.C. backs down on wireless smart meters- Customers will be able to pay extra for meters without wireless technology, says minister

 CBC News Posted: Jul 11, 2013 3:53 PM PT 

The $1 billion plan to install 1.8 million smart meters across B.C. has met with opposition because of the cost of the program, concerns about privacy and hacking of the systems, and possible health effects of the wireless technology.
The B.C. government won't force people to get a wireless BC Hydro smart meter if they don't want one, but they are likely going to pay an extra fee for the opting out of the system. Energy Minister Bill Bennett says the details are still being ironed out, but it is clear someone will have to pay the extra cost and it won't be those who have agreed to have the wireless meters installed. "The 96 per cent of B.C. ratepayers who have taken the smart meters should not pay the additional expense of the four per cent who don't want one," said Bennett. The details are still being ironed out but the extra costs would likely have to cover having the wireless component removed and employing meter readers to the non-wireless devices. According to the government there are about 60,000 household that have yet to have smart meters installed.

Sunday, June 16, 2013

Smart meters banned on Osoyoos reserve land

By Joe Fries - Penticton Western News Updated: June 14, 2013 10:42 AM
OIB Smart Meters Press Release
Citing “science-based evidence,” the Osoyoos Indian Band announced Thursday it would ban the installation of smart meters at 700 homes and businesses on reserve land.  “Having been presented with science-based evidence, the band council and I are convinced that Fortis’ proposed wireless smart meters in meshed-grid networks have the potential to harm our children and our environment,” Chief Clarence Louie said in a press release. “No scientist on the planet has been able to verify the safety of these extremely dangerous devices that emit microwave radiation 24/7 and which cannot be turned off.” The press release does not specify the science-based evidence upon which the council based its decision. Louie did not immediately respond to a request for comment Friday. (more)

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Refusal to accept smart meter leads to Peachland power cut


BC Hydro has turned off power to a Peachland residence after the homeowners replaced a smart meter with an uncertified analog meter.  Talking on the remaining battery of a cordless phone, Deborah Stutters told Capital News a BC Hydro truck with three to five employees showed up at her Princeton Avenue home Wednesday around 1 p.m. to cut the power to her house. Last May a representative of BC Hydro came to Stutters' house and said her analog meter was malfunctioning and they'd need to replace it. Stutters indicated she didn't want a smart meter and said she was assured the meter would be replaced with another analog meter. "Within hours somebody snuck on this property and switched out our analog for a smart meter," said Stutters. Stutters has electromagnetic field sensitivity and had declined getting the smart meter for health reasons. She said she and her husband were angry for being lied to. They purchased an analog meter from the United States and replaced the smart meter with it before mailing the smart meter back to BC Hydro. Cindy Verschoor, communications lead for BC Hydro's Smart Metering Program, said the installation of an uncertified meter ultimately led to Wednesday's "extremely unusual" power cut. "This was a very dangerous situation," said Verschoor. "BC Hydro could be liable for anything that went wrong if we knowingly supplied power to a meter that was purchased on the Internet. It wasn't installed by BC Hydro, it's not approved for use in Canada, we simply can't supply power to them through that meter." Stutters said she was informed her electricity would be disconnected because the analog meter wasn't certified to Canadian standards and wasn't installed by BC Hydro employees. She said she found a Canadian certified analog meter, which she offered to purchase herself if BC Hydro would install it. When asked why BC Hydro didn't go along with that suggestion, Verschoor said all meters have to meet "rigorous" safety requirements. "We simply can't accommodate a meter that doesn't meet all of our requirements, as well as all the federal and provincial requirements." Verschoor said BC Hydro doesn't stock analog meters anymore. She noted the five per cent of BC Hydro customers who still have analog meters aren't being forced to switchover "for the time being." Stutters said she is simply trying to find a solution that doesn't compromise her health. "We don't want to steal electricity, what we do want is some consideration for my health condition." As for the immediate future, Stutters isn't sure what to do next. Neighbours and friends have offered to let her store some food in their freezers before it goes bad. The family also runs an office out of their house with six employees. "Our livelihood depends on electricity in this house," said Stutters.


Thursday, January 31, 2013

BC Hydro: smart meters will not be forced on customers without their consent

Global News : Wednesday, January 30, 2013 12:00 AM 

Sunday, December 30, 2012

Eric Foster defends extension of meter installation

By Richard Rolke - Vernon Morning Star Published: December 30, 2012 1:00 AM
Eric Foster, Vernon-Monashee MLA, isn’t surprised public opposition has delayed smart meters. B.C. Hydro’s deadline to install smart meters has been extended from Dec. 31, 2012 to Dec. 31, 2013 and one of the reasons is customer concerns preventing the corporation from installing all of the devices. “There are people who don’t want them installed and it’s a matter of education,” said Foster, who supports the deadline extension. “Hydro did a mass education program and addressed concerns but when there are individuals with concerns, you have to go back and work your way through it.” Some people have claimed that microwave radiation exposure from the meters can create a range of health issues, while the utility will know what appliances a customer is using by monitoring the meter. Hydro has denied those claims and Foster believes the devices are necessary. “They aren’t a bad thing,” he said. “The second someone hits a power pole and takes out the power, they know instantly where it is and they can respond.” The other reasons provided for B.C. Hydro not meeting the Dec. 31, 2012 installation deadline are a shortage of qualified labour and equipment. Hydro says it has installed 93 per cent or 1.73 million of the 1.87 million smart meters scheduled for B.C. Leading up until Dec. 31, 2013, the utility says it will complete the final seven per cent of installations and address customer concerns. The NDP wants the B.C. Utilities Commission to get involved after the original deadline was missed. “This was a failure of public policy from the beginning,” said John Horgan, energy critic. “The Liberals are clearly not up to the challenges facing British Columbians, so it’s time to get some help. I’d like to see the B.C. Utilities Commission invited back to the table to help explore what options are out there to satisfy concerned consumers that want another choice.” According to Horgan, the Liberal government initiated the Clean Energy Act in 2010 with almost no debate among MLAs in the Legislature. “The act exempted the $1 billion smart meter program from the independent oversight of the BCUC,” he said.

Thursday, December 27, 2012

Smart Meter installation deadline extended


VICTORIA– BC Hydro has installed 93 per cent or 1.73 million of 1.87 million smart meters. To ensure the final seven per cent of smart meters can be installed, the Province is extending the deadline under the Clean Energy Act from Dec. 31, 2012, to Dec. 31, 2013.

Shortages in qualified labour, equipment and specialized meters, plus customer concerns, prevented BC Hydro from fully installing all smart meters in 2012. The additional time will enable BC Hydro to complete the work and address as many customer concerns as possible before finalizing smart meter installations. Smart meters are expected to pay for themselves by delivering $1.6 billion in benefits over 20 years. These are savings that BC Hydro will not have to collect from customers. Research has shown that some of the new tools available through smart meters will enable customers to conserve up to 15 per cent in energy costs. Smart meters will make possible new conservation tools like secure online customer accounts and optional in-home devices that will provide homeowners with up-to-date information about power use.Once smart meters are fully installed and operational, they will also let BC Hydro know of an outage immediately, so power can be restored faster.

Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Smart Meters Coming to Vernon

Don Quixote Update:
On Monday received  a letter dated Aug 11 from BC Hydro that they will be installing a new smart meter at my house within next few weeks. Apparently they will knock at my door before installation. It is my intention to inquire about cost of relocation option and to ensure that they check and certify that the base plate from existing meter is ok to hook up to. see http://vernonblog.blogspot.ca/2012/08/bc-hydro-offers-free-fix-if-meter.html
BC Hydro said the condition of the socket is the responsibility of the homeowner, but if installers find any problems with the equipment the utility will contact the homeowner and offer to bring in a qualified electrician to make the fix at Hydro's expense. The company said its smart meter crews have found about 1,000 sockets that were damaged by eroded wiring, improper socket installations and pre-existing electrical bypasses.

 -----------------------------------
Ad in Friday's Morning Star( May 26) indicates that Vernon will be getting a Smart meter installed at your residence and/or Place of Business.

There is no Opt Out Available but you can have Hydro install it at a place of your choice. (Outside building, Pole on your property at your expense.)  No idea of what this would cost as Hydro claims no-one has ever asked for this relocation option. (Be the first one to ask for the cost of this relocation !)

If you have your meter covered so installation is unable to be completed (Or you have  a sign saying NO SMART METER etc.) their protocol is to leave information so you can talk with a hydro smart meter facilitator who will try to persuade you of the merits of the Smart Meter Program.

Personally, I have no concerns and will allow a smart meter installation on my property. BUT like negative billing etc. I do believe that Hydro should allow an opt out opportunity for those who have concerns about the program. (Naturally extra costs for meter reading etc. will have to be borne by the opt out property owner.)


Friday, August 10, 2012

BC Hydro offers free fix if meter installers find hazard - Utility company says cracked smart meter socket could cause fire

BC Hydro says homeowners must share responsibility for electrical safety after two recent fires that followed the installation of smart meters, but the company is offering a free fix for problems that its workers may discover during the installation. Fires have occurred in homes in Mission and Coquitlam this summer after installation of the new meters. BC Hydro said a cracked meter base plate, or socket, may be the cause of at least one of the fires. BC Hydro said the condition of the socket is the responsibility of the homeowner, but if installers find any problems with the equipment the utility will contact the homeowner and offer to bring in a qualified electrician to make the fix at Hydro's expense. The company said its smart meter crews have found about 1,000 sockets that were damaged by eroded wiring, improper socket installations and pre-existing electrical bypasses. It said the risk of a smart meter installation causing an electrical problem is extremely low. It also said the new meters provide improved surge protection over the old meters. The company said homeowners should use a qualified electrician when they make any wiring changes to their homes and they should have their electrical system checked if they notice their lights are dimming, brightening, or flickering without apparent cause.

Tuesday, August 07, 2012

Smart meter fires spark concerns in B.C.

 CBC News Posted: Aug 7, 2012 5:49 AM PT
BC Hydro plans to install 1.8 million smart meters across B.C. by the end of 2012
BC Hydro plans to install 1.8 million smart meters across B.C. by the end of 2012
 
Questions are being raised about the safety of smart meters after fire crews were called to a home in Coquitlam over problems with the box — the second such incident in weeks. The latest incident happened at about 3 a.m. PT on Sunday morning. There was only minor damage to the home, said Coquitlam fire Chief Scott MacKenzie. He declined to comment further as the case has now been handed over to BC Hydro for a full investigation. Technicians had installed a smart meter at the residence — an older home — about a month ago, said a BC Hydro official. The incident comes after a Mission woman's house burnt down on June 15, just one day after a smart meter was installed there. A report by the Mission Fire Department said the fire originated at the base plate which the smart meter was plugged into. BC Hydro says the base is part of the house, so any damage or fault with the equipment is the responsibility of the homeowner. “There’s a lot of steps underway to ensure that everything is safe,” said BC Hydro spokeswoman Cindy Verschoor. “But that’s not to say that equipment can’t malfunction at any time." Surrey electrical contractor Bill Strain says problems can arise when the base plate is old or damaged. “If moisture entered into the [meter base], there could be corrosion, rusting or any number of things,” he said. The cases could point to a bigger problem nationwide. A recent report by the Ontario Fire Marshall says “initial research [showed] an unusual amount of fire incidents involving smart meters." The report, dated June 15, adds: “Anecdotal information supported problems occurred after the old analog meters were updated to the new digital smart meters.” BC Hydro says it has installed 1.5 million smart meters so far, and replaced about 1,000 faulty bases for free. Verschoor says customers should call immediately if they notice problems with flickering lights or any unusual dimming or brightening shortly after a smart meter is installed. BC Hydro is on track to replace some 1.8 million analog meters throughout the province by the end of the year. Smart meters are capable of providing hourly information about electricity consumption. The utility estimates the meters will save consumers $1.6 billion over the next 20 years by preventing the loss and theft of power. But there has been an intense revolt against smart meters in the province, with more than 15,000 residents signing petitions opposing the devices.

Saturday, August 04, 2012

‘Unusual’ number of fires, smart meters linked - Ontario fire marshal says faulty base plates could be the cause, similar to Mission blaze

By SCOTT SIMPSON, Vancouver SunAugust 3, 2012
Smart meter installations are the suspected cause of an “unusual” number of fires similar to a recent electrical fire at a home in Mission, according to a recent investigation by the Ontario fire marshal’s office.  BC Hydro is in the process of a $1-billion installation of the meters, which use wireless technology to transmit information about electricity consumption to power utilities, following the lead of provinces and states including Ontario and California. There’s no evidence to suggest that the meters themselves are overheating and catching fire, but it appears from an Ontario fire marshal’s report, dated June 15, 2012, that the base plates, or four-pronged sockets that meters plug into, can become compromised and start to burn if they’re old or suffer rough handling during installation. “It’s like everything else, once it’s installed and intact nothing usually happens,” said Surrey electrical contractor Bill Strain, a former president of the Canadian Home Builders Association. “A lot of times, when you pull something apart, if it’s been there for 30 years it’s probably going to be rusted in or hard in. So they have to give it a little bit of a jerk or a twist. That jerk or twist may be what sets the whole thing in motion,” Strain said Friday. If there’s a problem, he added, it’s possible that a contractor without formal electrical training may miss it. A resident of Mission, Trish Regan, recently lost her home in a fire that the district’s fire department said appeared to originate from a broken base plate that became overheated and caught fire a few hours after an employee of Corix, the company contracted by BC Hydro to install the meters, plugged one in at her home.

According to the marshal’s report, “During our initial research of the new meters we encountered an unusual amount of fire incidents involving smart meters. After discovering these incidents our main question was, were they one-off incidents or was there a similar systemic root cause  “Anecdotal information supported [the fact that] problems occurred after the old analog meters were updated to the new digital smart meters.”  The report noted the possibility of a fire resulting from “a loose connection in the meter base.” “What could be the reason for this? The old meter base connections may not have been in a condition for seamless exchange to a new meter. New meters may have defects that cause electrical failures or misalignment with old meter base. Careless installation during changeover.” Meter changeovers are not unusual; before the smart meter project, Hydro was replacing about 40,000 old analogue meters per year with new ones. In 0.5 per cent of cases, Hydro installers noted a faulty meter base and replaced it, according to smart meter deputy project officer Fiona Taylor. That’s more or less the same base plate replacement ratio that’s arising from the smart meter installation, she said. Cindy Verschoor, Hydro spokeswoman, said that unless a homeowner notices problems after the installation — such as lights flickering on and off, or dimming and brightening — there’s no need to worry about a problem with the plate. “If you notice anything unusual of course give us a call or arrange to have an electrician do an inspection,” Verschoor said. “You can tell by your lights. That’s the best indicator.” Verschoor said Corix installation supervisors are certified electricians and they’re always on standby to effect any plate repairs noted by the installers. (more)
----------
   Fire guts home after smart meter installed   BC Hydro says owner is responsible for ensuring safety

Monday, May 14, 2012

Vernon defends residents wanting to opt out of smart meters

Richard Rolke - Vernon Morning Star Published: May 14, 2012 5:00 PM
Vernon officials don’t want smart meters forced on to anyone.  Council unanimously voted Monday to urge B.C. Hydro to develop an opt-out procedure for people who don’t want the remote monitoring devices.  “I believe people should be given the right to decide what goes on their houses,” said Coun. Bob Spiers. Spiers points to Quebec where residents there can refuse meters as long as they cover the costs involved with traditional meter reading. Council’s decision comes after a presentation from Citizens for Safe Technology. The group claims microwave radiation exposure can create a range of health issues, while the utility will know what appliances you are using by monitoring the meter. B.C. Hydro insists the devices do not present a health concern and do not interfere with  privacy. “I have no concerns with smart meters and I’d have one in my house but people should have the right to opt out,” said Coun. Brian Quiring. While council’s motion will be forwarded to Hydro, there is little confidence the Crown corporation will shift direction. “Nothing will happen,” said Spiers. “B.C. Hydro won’t back down and we will all get smart meters.” However, Mayor Rob Sawatzky insists that local governments must provide their residents with a voice. “Hopefully those in power will reflect on this and consider what the community  wants,” he said.
---------
Vernon Council Seeks Opt-Out For Smart Meters Written by Peter McIntyre 107.5 KISSFM  Monday, 14 May 2012 19:00 Smart meterAfter several weeks of hearing both sides of the issue, Vernon council has passed a motion regarding smart meters. Council will ask BC Hydro to allow residents who don't want the wireless meters, to opt-out, providing those people pick up the extra costs. Councillor Patrick Nicol says council also wants Hydro to request 'optional refusal' from the BC Utilities Commission, the agency that regulates the utility. "So what has to happen as part of our motion is that, it simply be handled in a professional way by BC Hydro so they they ask for that opportunity for the citizens of BC which they represent." Councillor Bob Spiers says people should have to the right to decide what goes on their homes. "Quebec basically came up with a perfect solution, allowing people to opt out at a cost. This is almost looks like Rogers negative billing that happened a few years ago. Nothing is going to happen. BC Hydro is not going to back down and we're all going to get smart meters." Mayor Rob Sawatzky says council has done what it can on the issue, even though he's not sure BC Hydro will pay any attention to the city's concerns. "We can pass through citizen and community intent and hopefully those in power will reflect and make decisions that reflect the commuinity's wishes." Rob Sawatzky says it's about giving residents a choice. "Our recommendation, the intent of it was that, citizens be giving an option, similar to some other jurisdictions, where they would be able to retain their old meters at the appropriate cost to  them so they're not everyone else is subsidized their wish." A group called Citizens for Safe Technology wanted council to pass a moratorium on installing the devices over numerous concerns, even though health and utility officials say they are safe. Hydro expects to install the meters in the Greater Vernon area later this year.

Thursday, May 10, 2012

Penticton council defers fees for opting out of smart meters

By Steve Kidd - Penticton Western News Published: May 10, 2012 3:00 PM 
Penticton residents will have the option to choose to have a manual utility meter, but how much it will cost them to do so is still up in the air. At Monday night’s meeting, Penticton council adopted a policy that will allow residents to opt out of having Automatic Meter Reading devices — or smart meters — installed. Instead they will be able to choose the old-style meters that require a manual reading, on a monthly basis. But council didn’t accept the fee schedule proposed by staff, which would have seen residents paying $105 for a manual electric meter and $26.25 for each monthly reading. Water meters were priced at $40, with the same cost for readings, but only twice a year. The new policy started in January, when a small group began lobbying council about potential health concerns caused by the smart meters, which the city has been gradually switching over to since 2003. A public meeting in February, attended by 70 people, with only 15 asking questions, resulted in council directing staff to draft an opt-out policy. Moroziuk said staff used three principles as a foundation to draft the policy. First, that it is the role of federal authorities, not municipal, to evaluate health, safety and privacy concerns related to smart meters, and that the meters being used in Penticton meet federal and provincial regulations. The third principal was to lay the cost of opting out squarely on the shoulders of those that choose to do so. “All the costs associated with changing out the meters or reading the meters is being borne by the person who is making the request, it is not being borne by the other customers of the electrical or water utility,” said Moroziuk, explaining that the option will be available to everyone that has a smart meter, with the exception of those whose meters are in a bank, such as in a condo complex or apartment block. In that case, Moroziuk said, you could have anything from a single individual to everyone on the bank wanting to opt out. In those cases, he said, a decision from the strata council would be required, with costs being split among all members of the strata, including those that might have voted against the proposition. But it was the ongoing costs that stuck in the craw of some of the council members. “It does appear that these rates are rather onerous on the people wanting to opt out,” said Mayor Dan Ashton, echoing comments made by Coun. Andrew Jakubeit, who wondered if the frequency of meter readings couldn’t be reduced. Adding together staff and administration costs, Moroziuk said the $26.25 was what was needed to cover the extra cost of returning to reading individual meters. “We have no idea where these (opted-out) meters are going to be located. You go to one house, and the next might be five kilometres away, we don’t really know,” said Moroziuk. “We have made an assumption that it is going to take us 30 minutes per meter.” Considering that there are 17,000 electric utility customers in Penticton, chief financial officer Doug Leahy confirmed that using two systems for reading the meters would be costly. “Anytime we are starting to go outside of our normal procedure, then that takes extra time. If we were going to only bill select meters twice a year, then that is definitely going to take either the meter reader more time or accounting more time,” said Leahy. “There is definitely going to be a lot more manual intervention when we are trying to go to a system of more automated meter reading as it is. It is possible, certainly. But it doesn’t come without its work at a staff level.” Council eventually voted in favour of a motion brought forward by Coun. Garry Litke, that the city adopt the policy as presented by staff and delay the fees presented in the bylaw until there was a better picture of the costs. That, however, wasn’t enough for Kevin Proteau, one of the smart meter opponents, who had concerns that city staff was not consider all possibilities. “There is a lot more things that you have not taken into consideration … like low income families, singles and seniors that would not be able to afford the costs,” said Proteau, who offered to share information collected by his lobby group with the city. “We’ve done further studying than city staff has on other opt out programs,” he said. “Now that we have agreed that we should have an opt out program, we should look at all options.”

Tuesday, May 08, 2012

Enderby council pushes for smart meter opt-out clause

Richard Rolke - Vernon Morning Star Published: May 08, 2012 7:00 AM
  Enderby politicians don't want smart meters forced on to residents. Council voted Monday to ask B.C. Hydro to initiate an opt-out program for the contentious remote monitoring devices. "Many communities have agreed to do that already," said Mayor Howie Cyr. "We want to address the concerns of many residents out there." Council is also asking the Interior Health Authority to conduct tests on radiation levels in the community. B.C. Hydro has not indicated if customers will be allowed to opt out of meters. If that were to occur, customers would have to pay for traditional meter reading methods. Citizens for Safe Technology, which has asked for a ban on the devices, claims microwave radiation exposure can create a range of health issues, while the utility will know what appliances you are using by monitoring the meter. B.C. Hydro insists the devices do not present a health concern and do not interfere with  privacy. The Crown corporation still hasn't made a presentation to council on smart meters. "I've been told that Hydro has already been in the community installing meters and we had asked that they not be installed until we meet with them first," said Cyr. Cyr does not believe Hydro's introduction of smart meters was well thought out. "They should have educated the public first instead of just saying we're installing them," he said.

Tuesday, May 01, 2012

Vancouver council motions on smart meters and oil liability deferred to allow public input

By FRANK LUBA, The ProvinceMay 1, 2012 4:36 PM
Vancouver council decided Tuesday to move a decision about asking B.C. Hydro to allow residents to opt out of its controversial “smart meter” program to a committee meeting Wednesday because people want to speak on the issue.  But the motion, to be presented at the planning, transportation and environment committee, is unlikely to help meter-wary residents. Cindy Verschoor, part of Hydro’s smart meter program, said Tuesday that “the bottom line is we’re not offering an opt-out program.” The reason is that customers who had accepted the meters would have to pick up the extra costs incurred because of people not taking the meters — like having a dual metering system. Verschoor said customers can choose to have the meter installed in another location — although the customer would have to bear the cost of that change. But so far nobody has done that.
--------------
Don Quixote Note: Contrast this response given by Cindy Verschoor in Vernon as reported in an article by Richard Rolke of the Morning Star.

 http://vernonblog.blogspot.ca/2012/04/vernon-council-delays-potential-action.html
The Crown corporation is considering allowing customers to opt out of smart meters but officials state that a dual system would be costly. “The benefits would be eroded to all customers,” said Cindy Verschoor, manager of communications and public affairs.

Wednesday, April 25, 2012

B.C. Hydro makes pitch for devices

Jennifer Smith - Vernon Morning Star Published: April 25, 2012 1:00 AM
If you stood right next to a smart meter for 20 years the radio frequency exposure would be less than a 30-minute cell phone call, says B.C. Hydro.  The power utility is trying to ease safety concerns around smart meters, which are on track to be installed in the Greater Vernon area sometime this July. “Radio frequency is a part of everyday life, even the spark plugs in your car transmit radio frequency,” said Cindy Verschoor, B.C. Hydro’s communications manager. Following a recent anti-smart meter presentation from the Citizens for Safe Technology Society, B.C. Hydro cleared up some “misinformation” for Coldstream council Monday. CST claims the meters are unsafe, unhealthy and raise security issues. While the smart meters will help Hydro detect where power is being stolen, as well as outages, they do not monitor what devices are being powered and have no visibility into the home. They only send hourly consumption data to B.C. Hydro, which will also provide more accurate readings. “We have absolutely no intention of using this as a monitoring device on our customers,” said Gary Murphy, chief project officer. “This is something that we treat very, very seriously, not only our customer’s privacy but protection of our own system.” But as nearly two million smart meters get installed by the end of 2012, another issue is that residents have no choice in the matter. “For those people who have expressed concern, they don’t have an option,” said Coldstream Coun. Doug Dirk. Since residential users make up 33.3 per cent of Hydro’s customers (industrial and commercial share the remainder), it was also suggested that the utility hold off on forcing residents into the program. “It hasn’t really been confirmed yet as safe, reliable and accurate and there are concerns that maybe we are jumping into something that doesn’t need to be adopted so quickly,” said Coun. Richard Enns, who would like to see Hydro focus only on installing smart meters on industrial and commercial clients for now. While there is no opt-out program, work orders can be put on hold so concerns can be discussed. Coldstream did investigate a ban of smart meters and discovered municipalities do not have the authority to legally restrict the use of smart meters.
-------------
Don Quixote Note: OPT OUT OPTION:  http://vernonblog.blogspot.ca/2012/03/hydro-quebec-customers-can-opt-out-of.html The Gazette March 16, 2012
Hydro-Québec has modified its proposal for the planned rollout of smart meters to allow for an opt-out clause.  Customers who decide to not use a smart meter for health or other concerns would pay an extra $200 a year under a proposal filed Thursday with the Régie de l'énergie. Consumers choosing to opt out would pay an initial fee of $98 and then $17 a month to cover the cost of manually reading the meters. The cost would be $302 the first year and $204 each year thereafter.

Choice to opt out of smart meters unclear (excerpt below)
California's public utilities commission recently ruled that residential customers who are concerned about the safety of smart meters should be allowed to opt out of its program, but at their own expense.
Customers would be subject to a $90 initial fee and then a monthly charge of $10 for having the analog meter read manually.
 --------------------------

B.C. Hydro also offers the option of having the meter placed (buried?) on some other part of your property. No cost estimates were given but it is apparently part of the BC Hydro Tariffs approved by the B.C. Utilities Commission. BC Hydro told Vernon Council that no one has ever used this method of relocating the meter in the 1,072,000 smart meters installed to date.

Vernon council delays potential action on meters

By Richard Rolke -  Vernon Morning Star Published: April 25, 2012 1:00 AM
Attempts to limit the use of smart meters have been pushed off again at Vernon city hall.  Coun. Bob Spiers made a motion Monday calling on B.C. Hydro to allow customers to opt out of remote monitoring devices, but the rest of council deferred the matter until May 14. “People should not make a decision immediately after a delegation,” said Coun. Mary-Jo O’Keefe referring to the presentation council had just received from B.C. Hydro. She also pointed out that city policies require council not to deal with matters related to a presentation until the next meeting. Spiers made a similar motion March 26 after a presentation from a group opposed to smart meters. The issue was delayed until council could hear from B.C. Hydro. “People should have some say over it,” said Spiers of why he favours an opt-out clause for residents who believe the devices are not safe. On Monday, Gary Murphy, B.C. Hydro chief project officer, defended smart meters. “We are making a much needed investment in infrastructure that is the backbone of our economy,” he said of B.C.’s power grid. He added that a more efficient system will save energy and money and keep rates low. “We will eliminate the need for estimated bills and there will be no more meter reading errors.” The Crown corporation is considering allowing customers to opt out of smart meters but officials state that a dual system would be costly. “The benefits would be eroded to all customers,” said Cindy Verschoor, manager of communications and public affairs. Council also heard from Greg Baytalan, an environmental health officer with the Interior Health Authority. “If smart meters, which are well below Health Canada safety six (requirements), then we should have a concern with everything else including driving,” he said. Baytalan says the radiation exposure from smart meters is far below that generated by cellular phones, microwave  ovens and baby monitors.“Smart meters are intermittent (with the signal). If you add up the whole day, it’s one minute,” he said.  While he wants customers to have the right to refuse smart meters, Spiers doesn’t believe there is a health concern. “It’s just a small amount,” he said of radiation. Coun. Juliette Cunningham says B.C. Hydro’s approach has created a level of public mistrust. “I have citizens coming with their concerns and they feel they have no voice,” she said.
----------
Don Quixote Note: The motion that I proposed and was deferred at both meetings was: Moved by 'THAT Council directs staff to forward a letter to BC Hydro in support of optional refusal of installation of wireless smart meters for citizens of British Columbia; AND FURTHER, that the letter be copied to the Premier and all UBCM Member Municipalities.'

This motion will be debated at the May 14 meeting. The motion that the Advocates against Smart Meters were asking for was for a moratorium on the the installation of all smart meters. I can not support that motion and would reject it if Council brings it forward at the May 14 meeting.

see also:  http://vernonblog.blogspot.ca/2012/03/hydro-quebec-customers-can-opt-out-of.html

Wednesday, April 11, 2012

City replacing defective water meter transmitters

After less than a quarter of their projected lifespan, Fort St. John's water meters have a failing part that needs to be replaced. Water meters that transmit water usage electronically to City Hall were installed in residences and businesses in the city between 2006 and 2008. A unit separate from the water meter called a meter transmitter unit, or MTU, reads the meter and sends it to City Hall via radio frequency. However, starting in July of last year, the City began receiving complaints of water bills being estimated instead of exact. Upon investigation, it was found that the batteries in the transmitter units were failing or had died, despite having a 20 year warranty. The company that provided the units, Aclara, determined there was an issue with the initial programming that reduced the life span of their batteries. Currently, approximately half of the MTUs in the city - 3,000 - are now dead or dying, and eventually all will need to be replaced. Aclara is providing warranty on the MTUS, but it is pro-rated, and the cost to replace them is not covered. The new MTUs are also an upgrade from the current ones, and will cost an additional $45 each for the ability to communicate two ways. Once the  new units have been received, 15-minute long appointments will be booked with residents for replacement, with accomodation for schedules. Priority will go to those with already dead or dying batteries. The rest are expected to fail over the next year. After installation, the new MTU will automatically transmit the correct reading, and adjustments will be made to the owner's water bill. If residents are concerned that the estimates they are being charged now are significantly incorrect, they can also call City Hall at the end of the month and give them their water meter reading.